Experience Life Magazine

Expert Answers: On Weight Machines, Body-Fat Percentage, and improving lung capacity

Our fitness experts tackle your questions on the best weight machines, improving lung capacity, and more.


What weight machines should I use?









Q1: I’ve heard that free weights offer advantages over machines. If so, are there any weight machines that are worth using?

A: Free weights do offer advantages over machines. Most important, they give you freedom to move naturally, says Lou Schuler, CSCS, coauthor of The New Rules of Lifting Supercharged. “Your body is designed to push, pull, run, jump, lift, carry, and throw. When you stick to moves that use the body the way you would use it for survival, that’s how you properly develop muscles.”

Free weights also allow you to combine movements and work multiple muscle groups at once, which adds a cardiovascular challenge, making your workout more efficient and comprehensive.

Some weight machines, however, may be worth incorporating into your routine. Your deciding factor should be how much versatility a machine allows: Does it force your body to move in a certain way, or does it let you control your movement pattern and range of motion?

Most cable-pulley systems fall into the latter category. Cable exercises typically allow movement through multiple planes and require core stabilization, making them similar to free-weight exercises, says Schuler. And since you can perform many exercises while standing, some movements, such as a chest press, can actually become more full-body than when done with dumbbells or a barbell. The best cable machines allow you to widen, narrow, raise, or lower your hand or foot position, or perform a move on one side of your body at a time. This allows you to do an endless variety of exercises specific to your goals.

Fixed-arm machines allow for only rigid movements and reduce the need to engage core muscles or small stabilizer muscles. This prevents you from developing the stability and kinesthetic awareness required for most real-world movements.

A good example of this limitation is the hip-adductor machine, which involves sitting and squeezing your inner thighs together. Use this piece of equipment regularly and, yes, you will build strong adductor muscles. But your inner-thigh muscles are not intended to squeeze heavy loads while in a seated position; they’re intended to fire as you lower into a wide squat.

If you want to improve how your adductors function while squatting, running, or doing other natural movements, says Schuler, try sumo or plié squats instead. “You’re better off strengthening your adductors in tandem with all the other muscles they are supposed to work with.”

There is one exception. Such isolated movements may be warranted when a physical therapist prescribes them for the purpose of activating and strengthening a weak or injured muscle. But be wary of continuing the protocol for too long. You should eventually progress to more-functional, multijoint movements that do not require machines. — Nicole Radziszewski

What’s the best way to measure body-fat percentage?







Q1: Is it important to know my body-fat percentage? What is the most accurate way to measure it?

A: Since neither weight nor body mass index (BMI) distinguishes between muscle and fat, your body-fat percentage is a better indicator of your body composition and overall health. It is the measurement that reveals when a lightweight individual has a disproportionate amount of body fat, or when someone with a muscular physique is leaner than the scale suggests, says Marc Perry, CSCS, CPT, a New York City–based personal trainer and founder of BuiltLean.com.

Body fat affects a lot: your life expectancy, how you look in a pair of jeans, how fast you can run. In excess, it can contribute to health conditions such as cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, and cancer. Conversely, lowering your body fat relative to your body weight can help improve health and athletic performance in most sports.

A number of methods can estimate your body-fat percentage — the most accurate and least expensive option being the three-site skinfold caliper test, which is used by most certified personal trainers. During this procedure, an expert uses a caliper to pinch and measure fat at three sites on the body (different for men and women). These measurements are then used in an equation to determine body-fat percentage.

Handheld devices or scales that estimate body-fat percentage use a method called bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA). These readings fluctuate based on hydration and have been found to be less accurate than caliper measurements, Perry says. For individuals who are 40 or more pounds overweight, Perry advises using BIA to get a baseline measurement, since getting an accurate reading from a caliper can be challenging. He also suggests people test at the same time each day — preferably first thing in the morning, after using the bathroom.

Once you know your approximate body-fat percentage, you’ll need to refer to a chart to interpret what the number means for you. Women typically have a higher percentage than men do, and body fat naturally increases with age. The American Council of Exercise provides the chart “Percent Body Fat Norms for Men and Women”. — Nicole Radziszewski 

Can I improve my lung capacity?









Q3: Are there breathing or strength-building exercises I can do to build my lung capacity?

A: “The short answer is no,” says Susan Hopkins, MD, PhD, professor of medicine and radiology at the University of California, San Diego. The lung is one organ you cannot really train, and there is little we can do to change it. “When it comes to lung capacity and ability to exchange oxygen, you have pretty much everything you are going to have by the time you reach the age of 12.”

That said, you can take steps to tone the muscles that help you inhale and exhale.

“If your breathing muscles get fatigued, breathing breaks down, and then you become even more fatigued,” explains sports physiologist Mike Bracko, EdD. That can lead to poor posture, which perpetuates the cycle. Picture the slouch of a marathon runner on mile 24: She’s tired and her shoulders are slouched forward. In this posture, her chest muscles are contracted and she’s not engaging her core muscles, which are vital for efficient respiration. Her posture limits her ability to get air in her lungs, and less air further increases her fatigue.

So how do you boost the fitness of your lung-supporting muscles? It’s the same way you do it for your body. According to Bracko, any kind of training — whether it’s steady-state cardio or anaerobic intervals — helps tone those hidden-but-vital muscles.

You also can strengthen your respiratory muscles by blowing out and breathing in against resistance, adds Hopkins. Specially designed breathing masks that provide resistance to air intake and expulsion are available. Blowing up a balloon or trying to breathe in through a narrow tube like a straw will provide the same benefit for a fraction of the cost. — Wendy Watkins 

like reading subscription ad

Nicole Radziszewski is a freelance writer, personal trainer, and frequent Experience Life contributor. Wendy Watkins is a personal trainer and freelance journalist based in Maine.

Related Content

Expert Answers

Expert Answers:

Expert Answers: Stretching, Sauna Etiquette, and Hot Yoga

“Your Qs: On Stretching, Sauna Etiquette, and Hot Yoga”…continued

Expert Answers

Expert Answers

Expert Answers: Elliptical Machines, Giving Blood, Protein and More

Your Qs: Choosing an elliptical, giving blood, and how much protein you really need.…continued

Expert Answers

Expert Answers: Healthy Weight Gain, Knee Pain and More

Expert Answers: Healthy Weight Gain, Avoiding Knee Pain During Exercise and More

We get the pros to answer your questions on the best exercises during menstruation, gaining…continued

Expert Answers Fitness Fixes


Expert Answers: Picking a Personal Trainer, Resting Between Sets and More

We get the pros to answer your questions on picking a good personal trainer, optimal activity…continued

Expert Answers


Expert Answers: HIIT for Weight Loss, Joint Pain and More

We get the pros to answer your questions on high-intensity interval training for weight loss,…continued

Expert Answers


Expert Answers: Speed, Pushups and More

We get the pros to answer your questions on upping your running pace, pushups, hotel workouts…continued

Expert Answers


Expert Answers on Digesting Protein, Exercising During a Detox and More

We ask the experts how much protein you can digest, if you should exercise during a detox, if…continued

Expert Answers


Expert Answers on Resistance Training and Flexibility, Drinking and Working Out, and More

Jen Sinkler, fitness editor, asks the experts if resistance training causes inflexibility, if…continued

Expert Answers


Expert Answers on Thick Trapezius Muscles, Injury-Related Pounds and More

Fitness editor Jen Sinkler asks the experts how to avoid building thick “traps,” shed…continued

One Comment to Expert Answers: On Weight Machines, Body-Fat Percentage, and improving lung capacity

  • Mitchell Keyes says:

    MOST BIA assessments have varying inaccuracies. Life Time Fitness has a method of assessing via BIA that has shown to have a .98 accuracy correlation to the gold standard (DEXA) of bodyfat analysis. It’s accuracy lies within adhering to protocol.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

City and state are only displayed in our print magazine if your comment is chosen for publication.

Experience Life welcomes your comments and suggestions. We simply ask that they be on topic and respectful of the conversation. Here's our full comment policy.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>